• 0 Posts
  • 29 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023





  • This and a couple other comments in this thread point to an aspect of Star Trek’s world building that hasn’t sat right with me for a long time. It’s supposed to be an utopianistic, egalitarian future. There’s no scarcity or need on Earth so everyone is supposed to be here because they want to be, out of a love of exploration and scientific advancement. So why is there such a disparity in treatment based on rank? Why does an ensign get stuck with a bunk in a hallway while Captain Picard gets a cushy executive suite? O’Brien at least had real quarters to raise his family in, but they were a comparative closet next to the bachelor Captain’s. Doesn’t seem right to me.

    All to say that, in my mind, if an ensign needs to stick to a manner of dress, so should an officer of rank. They’re all part of the same fleet and deserving of the same respect.





  • I think your comment could reasonably apply to early Discovery and Picard, but not so much to the rest of nuTrek. It could equally apply to DS9 and Enterprise - but not so much to the rest oldTrek (Voyager might straddle the line).

    I think it’s most accurate to say that Star Trek as a whole has generally shown alternating waves of reifying and challenging the utopian future concept. Overall that gives a message that a better society can be achieved, but the work of living up to that vision can never end. It works for me.


  • Your thoughts more or less match my own. Some really good concepts and actors were mostly wasted on lacklustre execution. As a Trekkie, I’m especially disappointed that Jeri Ryan was so underutilized. She could have killed as a vampire if she were given a little more to do.

    I did catch the first sequel, and appreciated its use of some of the less celebrated lore like

    spoiler

    distracting a vampire with knotted rope

    though how that’s supposed to tie into the

    spoiler

    Judas

    backstory I really don’t know.












OSZAR »